Cross-colony circulation of colonial bills of creditWe dispute Grubb's contention (Grubb, 2003, p. 1779) that colonial bills of credit “circulated inside, but not outside, the colony of issue.” We agree with a Maryland resident who wrote in 1787 that “Under the circumstances of America before the war, there was a mutual tacit consent that the paper of each colony should be received by its neighbours” (Hanson, 1787, p. 24). Since Grubb’s AER paper pertains mostly to the Confederation and early Federal eras, this matter may appear to be unimportant to the argument presented in the AER. Placed in the proper context, however, it is of critical importance. Grubb’s papers are all based on the assumption that in early America, the medium of exchange can be inferred from the unit of account recorded in certain classes of transactions. In Grubb’s AER paper, the dating of the transition to the dollar plays a critical role in Grubb’s econometrics and in his narrative history. The bulk of Grubb’s evidence on the dating of the transition is presented in a separate conference volume paper (Grubb, 2004a) and is based on Grubb’s analysis of the unit of account recorded in a series of indentured servant contracts preserved in a bound volume at the Historical Society of Pennsylvania, a volume known as “Redemptioner’s A.” To buttress the argument that the early American medium of exchange can be inferred in this way, Grubb has also published an article attempting to infer how much of colonial Pennsylvania’s medium of exchange was specie and how much was paper, by examining the unit of account mentioned in colonial runaway ads published in the Pennsylvania Gazette (Grubb 2004b). The difficulty, from Grubb’s standpoint, is that the great majority of rewards offer a sum in “Pennsylvania pounds,” while little or no mention is made of “New Jersey pounds” or the pounds of any other colony. In our view, this is to be expected, since “Pennsylvania pounds” represented an accounting concept, not a medium of exchange. We fully expect that many rewards mentioning a sum in “Pennsylvania pounds” were paid in gold, silver, or the paper money of New Jersey or some other colony rather than in Pennsylvania bills of credit. Grubb, however, has staked his entire argument, in each of his papers, on his ability to infer the medium of exchange from just such records. Therefore, Grubb must and does conclude that New Jersey’s bills of credit (to take a specific example) did not actually circulate in Pennsylvania. This conclusion we believe is not supported by the available evidence. John McCusker (1978, p 169) wrote of New Jersey’s bills of credit that “Their history is exceptional only in the demand for them in the neighboring colonies of New York and Pennsylvania. One estimate suggests that up to two-thirds of the paper money of New Jersey circulated outside the colony.” Thomas L. Purvis (1986, p. 170) described New Jersey’s bills of credit during the French and Indian War in these words: “As the war stimulated commercial activity in nearby provinces, it nevertheless aggravated the usual tendency for the colony’s money to pass among its neighbors. Writing in 1759, when the exchange rate for £100 sterling had already dropped to £156 Jersey, the English diarist Andrew Burnaby reported the currency to be ‘preferred by the Pensylvanians and New-Yorkers, even to that of their own provinces.’” If New Jersey paper money circulated as a medium of exchange in colonial Pennsylvania, as we believe it did, then Grubb’s papers (2003, 2004a, and 2004b) are built on a false premise and he has not succeeded in dating America’s transition to the dollar. |